Skip to content

Best Gym Clipboards for Tracking Sets and Reps

·14 min read·by

The best best gym clipboards for tracking sets and reps is the Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women, a 160-page bound log sized at 5.8 by 8.2 inches with a 4.7 out of 5 reported rating. It's the pick for anyone who wants one book to carry through a full training year.

Want a planner-style layout instead? The Fitness Workout Journal Women & Men covers that angle, as long as you don't need the deeper page count the Mr. Pen offers.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Below you'll see the specs that actually change how a gym log feels in your hands: page size, binding, and how many sets fit on a line. If you track everything in a phone app already, skip this category entirely.

Everything here comes from current Amazon listing data, manufacturer specifications and each product's owner track record. We haven't physically handled these journals, and we'd rather tell you that up front.

Quick Answer: The Best Gym Clipboards for Tracking Sets and Reps

The Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women takes the top spot for its 160-page capacity and the highest reported rating in this lineup.

Thinking about a phone app or a rigid board instead? Jump to Who Should NOT Buy below before you spend anything.

Comparison Table

Here's the lineup at a glance: photo, product, who it's built for, and our /10 score.

PhotoProductBest forScoreBuy
Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal WomenMr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal WomenFull-Year Logging for Solo Lifters9.1/10Check price →
Fitness Workout Journal Women & MenFitness Workout Journal Women & MenPlanner-Style Weekly Training Notes8.7/10Check price →
gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Womengisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men WomenMulti-Pack Value for Busy Bags8.9/10Check price →
Taja Fitness Workout Journal & LogTaja Fitness Workout Journal & LogAll-in-One Journal and Planner8.4/10Check price →
Fitness Planner Women & MenFitness Planner Women & MenWeight Loss and Progress Tracking8.1/10Check price →

Scroll sideways on small screens to see every column.

Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women: Best Overall for Year-Round Tracking

#1Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women
Mr.160 pages, 5.8 x 8.2 inches
9.1OUT OF 10
Tracking layout9.2
Durability9.0
Portability9.0
Owner verdict9.2
**This is the pick for lifters who want one bound book covering a full training year.** It runs 160 pages at 5.8 by 8.2 inches, which is deep enough to hold months of sessions without you buying a replacement mid-program.
The listing carries a 4.7 out of 5 reported rating, the strongest owner track record in this lineup. Each session page has slots for exercise, sets, reps and load, so you’re not drawing your own grid on a blank sheet.
**Flaws but not dealbreakers.** There’s no dedicated cardio or warm-up field, so mixed training gets squeezed into the margins. It’s also a bound book rather than a hard-backed board, meaning mid-set writing needs a flat surface under it.
If you’d rather tear off one sheet per workout and keep several pads going at once, the gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women lower down solves that with three separate pads.
⚠
Care: Keep paper logs out of the sweaty pocket of your gym bag. Moisture is the most common way a perfectly good journal gets ruined, and a zip pouch fixes it for good.
Pros
  • ✓160 pages at 5.8 x 8.2 inches, the deepest single-book capacity here
  • ✓4.7 out of 5 reported rating, the highest in this lineup
  • ✓Dedicated fields for exercise, sets, reps and load
  • ✓Bound format keeps a full year of history in one place
Cons
  • ✕No separate cardio or warm-up section
  • ✕Softcover design needs a flat surface for standing writes
  • ✕Single book means no backup if you leave it at home
Page Size
5.8 x 8.2 in
Length
160 pages
Tracking Fields
Sets, reps, load
Rating
4.7 / 5
Best for: One lifter who wants a single book covering an entire training year.

Fitness Workout Journal Women & Men: Best Planner-Style Layout

#2Fitness Workout Journal Women & Men
FitnessLog book and planner in one
8.7OUT OF 10
Tracking layout8.8
Durability8.6
Portability8.5
Owner verdict8.8
**This is the one to grab if you like your training to sit inside a weekly plan rather than a rolling list.** It works as both a workout log book and a planner, so you can map the week ahead and tick sessions off as they happen.
Verified buyer feedback consistently lands at 4.6 out of 5, and the structured weekly spread is the detail owners bring up most. That structure is what keeps a logged program visible instead of buried on page 40.
**Flaws but not dealbreakers.** Planner pages give you fewer lines per session, so a six or seven exercise day gets cramped. It also doesn’t match the page depth of the top pick.
If raw capacity matters more than weekly planning, the Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women up top packs 160 pages into a single book.
⚠
Planning: Planner-style pages reward a repeatable weekly routine. If your training days shift around constantly, a plain log page is easier to live with than a dated spread.
Pros
  • ✓Works as a planner and a session log in one book
  • ✓4.6 out of 5 reported rating across owner reviews
  • ✓Weekly structure keeps program adherence visible
  • ✓Built for both women and men running similar programs
Cons
  • ✕Fewer lines per session than a pure log page
  • ✕Less total page depth than the top pick
  • ✕Planner structure feels forced if your schedule moves weekly
Format
Log book + planner
Tracking Fields
Sets, reps, load
Audience
Women and men
Rating
4.6 / 5
Best for: Lifters who want their log to double as a weekly training plan.

gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women: Best Value Multi-Pack

#3gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women
gisgfim3 pads, 210 sheets total
8.9OUT OF 10
Tracking layout9.0
Durability8.7
Portability9.1
Owner verdict8.8
**Three separate pads is the whole point here, and it solves a problem no single journal can.** You get three 4 by 8 inch pads with 70 sheets each, which works out to 210 sheets before you need to buy anything again.
A 4 by 8 inch sheet fits inside a jacket pocket or a small gym bag pouch, so a pad can live in the car, one in your training bag and one at home. The reported rating sits at 4.7 out of 5, matching the top pick.
**Flaws but not dealbreakers.** Tear-off pads don’t survive a full year as a permanent record, because loose sheets get lost. The narrow sheet also leaves less room for notes than an A5 or 5.8 by 8.2 inch book.
If a permanent archive matters to you, the Fitness Planner Women & Men near the bottom keeps everything bound in one A5 book.
⚠
Storage: Loose sheets vanish. Snap a phone photo of each completed pad page before you file or bin it, or keep the pads together in one folder.
Pros
  • ✓Three pads totaling 210 sheets for the price of one book
  • ✓4.7 out of 5 reported rating, tied for best in this lineup
  • ✓4 x 8 inch sheets slip into a pocket or bag pouch
  • ✓One pad can live in each location so you never skip a log
Cons
  • ✕Loose sheets are easy to lose once torn off
  • ✕Each pad holds 70 sheets, so a heavy trainer refills sooner
  • ✕Narrow format leaves less width for extra notes
Page Size
4 x 8 in
Sheets
70 per pad
Pack
3 pads (210 sheets)
Rating
4.7 / 5
Best for: Lifters who want a pad in the bag, the car and the house all at once.

Taja Fitness Workout Journal & Log: Best All-in-One Format

#4Taja Fitness Workout Journal & Log
TajaJournal plus log pages
8.4OUT OF 10
Tracking layout8.5
Durability8.3
Portability8.2
Owner verdict8.6
**Think of the Taja as the middle path: part journal, part log book, part planner.** If you want to write a sentence about how a session felt alongside the set and rep numbers, this format gives you room a stripped-back log page doesn’t.
Owner feedback holds at 4.6 out of 5. It’s built to suit both women and men, which matters if you and a training partner share the same program and want matching books.
**Flaws but not dealbreakers.** All-in-one designs rarely do every job perfectly, and mixed pages mean the log grid can be tighter than on a dedicated log book. Thin covers also show wear faster in a crowded gym bag.
If you want a cleaner grid and more of it, the Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women is the more focused tool.
⚠
Wear: Soft covers crease and scuff with heavy bag use. A cheap elastic band or a slim sleeve keeps the pages flat for the whole training block.
Pros
  • ✓Journal, log and planner pages all in one book
  • ✓4.6 out of 5 reported rating from owner reviews
  • ✓Suits women and men training the same programs
  • ✓Room for mood and notes next to the numbers
Cons
  • ✕Mixed-purpose pages mean a tighter log grid
  • ✕Soft cover scuffs quickly with daily bag carry
  • ✕Highest overall score gap versus the top pick
Format
Journal + log book
Type
Fitness planner
Audience
Women and men
Rating
4.6 / 5
Best for: Lifters who want numbers and notes living on the same page.

Fitness Planner Women & Men: Best for Weight Loss Tracking

#5Fitness Planner Women & Men
FitnessA5 pages, 5.8 x 8.25 in
8.1OUT OF 10
Tracking layout8.2
Durability8.0
Portability8.0
Owner verdict8.2
**This one is built for people whose main goal is body change, not just heavier lifts.** It’s an A5 book at 5.8 by 8.25 inches, and the page design leans on daily health and wellness entries alongside gym, bodybuilding and weight loss progress.
The reported rating holds at 4.6 out of 5. If you’re tracking bodyweight, measurements and daily habits as well as sets and reps, this format gives those numbers a dedicated home instead of a margin scribble.
**Flaws but not dealbreakers.** Serious strength athletes will find the workout grid shallower than a dedicated log book. It’s also the lowest scoring pick here, mostly because generalist planners trade depth for breadth.
If pure set-and-rep logging is your only job, the gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women keeps things simpler with three tear-off pads.
⚠
Sizing: A5 is compact, roughly the size of a small paperback. If you write large or track six exercises a session, the smaller page fills fast.
Pros
  • ✓A5 format at 5.8 x 8.25 inches, easy to carry daily
  • ✓4.6 out of 5 reported rating from verified buyers
  • ✓Built around weight loss and bodybuilding progress
  • ✓Daily health and wellness entries alongside gym logs
Cons
  • ✕Gym grid is shallower than a dedicated log book
  • ✕A5 pages fill quickly for high-volume sessions
  • ✕Broad focus means less depth on strength numbers
Page Size
5.8 x 8.25 in
Size Class
A5
Focus
Weight loss, gym
Rating
4.6 / 5
Best for: Anyone tracking body change, daily habits and gym sessions in one A5 book.

Buying Guide: Page Size, Tracking Fields, Format and Durability

A gym log only works if you actually carry it, and that decision comes down to four things. Here's what separates the five picks above.

How much page do you actually need?

Sheet size changes everything about how a journal feels in use. These picks span 4 by 8 inches on a tear-off pad up to 5.8 by 8.2 inches in a bound book.

  • 4 x 8 inches fits a jacket pocket and works for straight sets and reps. That's the gisgfim pad format.
  • 5.8 x 8.2 inches gives you more width for exercise names and notation on one line. That's the Mr. Pen book.
  • 5.8 x 8.25 inches at A5 is the standard planner size, familiar and easy to find sleeves for. The Fitness Planner Women & Men uses this.

If you write big or track six or more exercises per session, go wider. If you log on a bench between sets with one hand, smaller and lighter wins.

What fields belong on a page?

A useful log page needs exercise name, sets, reps and load at minimum. All five products here cover that core group.

Where they differ is what sits around the edges. Planner-style books add weekly scheduling blocks. The weight-loss focused pick adds bodyweight and habit tracking.

If you want an extra element, the relevant field is where you'll find it.

One tip from buyer feedback: fill in the exercise list before you train, then just add numbers as you go. Logging mid-session slows you down, and consistency drops.

Bound book, planner or tear-off pad?

This is the biggest fork in the road, and it's about how you train rather than how much you lift.

  • A bound book keeps a full training year together. Great for periodised programs where you need last month's numbers. The Mr. Pen and Taja books fit here.
  • A planner puts a weekly structure in front of you before you start. Helpful if adherence is your weak point.
  • Tear-off pads suit people who train in more than one place and hate carrying anything. The gisgfim pack gives you three.

There's no wrong answer, just a mismatch risk. Buy a planner when your week never repeats and you'll resent it by week three.

Will it survive a gym bag?

Paper is paper, and every product here is paper. What you can control is where it lives.

Soft covers crease. Loose sheets get lost. Sweaty kit ruins pages faster than anything else.

A simple zip pouch costs very little and extends the life of any of these books by months.

If you're also building out kit at home, it's worth getting your home gym setup basics sorted so the equipment and the logging habit grow together.

Worth knowing: the American College of Sports Medicine publishes resistance-training progression guidance that assumes you're tracking load over time. A log book is what makes that progression visible, and the national activity guidelines set the weekly training volume most people are aiming for.

To see how these factors play out on real picks, compare the Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women, Fitness Workout Journal Women & Men and the gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women reviewed above.

Using a Garmin at the Gym, 5 PRACTICAL TIPS YOU SHOULD KNOWvia Aesthetic AL

Who Should NOT Buy Best Gym Clipboards for Tracking Sets and Reps

This category is the wrong purchase for a few kinds of buyers. Here's who they are, and what to look at instead.

You Need Automatic Tracking and Reminders

If you want your numbers to sync, chart themselves and nudge you when a lift stalls, paper does none of that. A training app handles progression charts and reminders better than any journal.

Paper wins on focus and zero distraction. If that isn't your problem, a notebook won't fix it.

You Train Somewhere Without a Flat Surface

Every product here is softcover or a paper pad. None of them have a rigid backing, so they depend on a bench, a ledge or a wall.

If you train in a garage or a park with nowhere to write, pair one of these with a proper clipboard, or look at rigid-backed log books instead. That's a real constraint, not a nitpick.

You Already Track Everything on Your Phone

If your phone logging is consistent and you review it, adding a paper book just gives you two systems to maintain. Two systems means neither gets updated properly.

Honest answer: this is the most common reason people buy a journal and abandon it. If you're already tracking well, spend the money on something else. And if consistency itself keeps slipping, the common training sticking points are usually the real issue, not the tool.

Final Verdict

The Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women is still the pick. It combines 160 pages, a 5.8 by 8.2 inch sheet and a 4.7 out of 5 reported rating, which is the strongest overall package in this lineup.

Want a weekly plan built into the pages? Get the Fitness Workout Journal Women & Men. It trades some page count for structure, which is a fair swap if adherence is your weak spot.

Need a pad in every location? The gisgfim 3 Fitness Journal Men Women gives you 210 sheets across three separate pads.

If your goal is body change rather than heavier lifts, the Fitness Planner Women & Men puts weight loss and daily habits on the same page as your sessions.

One last thing: read the Who Should NOT Buy section above before you order. If you're already tracking well on your phone, none of these five will help you.

Strong VS Hevy Workout Tracker | Which One Is Better?via AJ Faith & Fitness

FAQ

What's the best Gym Clipboards for Tracking Sets and Reps overall?

The Mr. Pen Fitness Workout Journal Women, based on its 160-page capacity, 5.8 by 8.2 inch page size and the highest reported rating here at 4.7 out of 5. It's the pick for one lifter who wants a single book covering a full training year.

Is a gym journal better than a phone app?

It depends on why you're logging. Paper keeps you off your phone mid-session and never runs out of battery, but it can't chart progression automatically or send reminders. Apps win on analysis, journals win on focus.

How long does one workout journal last?

Roughly based on the sheet counts here: the Mr. Pen book has 160 pages, each gisgfim pad has 70 sheets and the Taja and Fitness Planner books run as bound volumes.

Training four times a week, a 70-sheet pad lasts about four months at one page per session. A 160-page book covers longer, depending on whether you log one page per session or one per week.

Can I use these for both strength training and cardio?

Yes, with a caveat. These are designed around sets, reps and load, so cardio gets squeezed into notes space on most pages. The Fitness Planner Women & Men handles daily health entries better than the pure log books.

Does the page size actually matter?

More than most buyers expect. A 4 by 8 inch pad fits a pocket but fills fast with long exercise names. A 5.8 by 8.2 inch book gives more width, which is why it's the more common choice for lifters logging six or more exercises.

How do I keep my log from getting ruined in a gym bag?

Keep it out of the sweaty compartment and consider a small zip pouch, which is the cheapest fix available. If you want the details on how these guides are put together, see our editorial approach, and you can always reach out to us with a question. You can read the disclosure on how we earn from qualifying purchases, and full details sit in our terms of use.

Share.

Similar Posts

Share